Skip to main content

Review of The Old Man and the Sea - Jashan Takhar

To say the least, reading, thinking about, and understanding  The Old Man and the Sea is... a unique experience. 

I have been recommended this book multiple times but never really took it upon myself to read it. From what I had heard about the novel, it sounded like a very linear and stodgy read. I finally decided to give it a try and confirmed my hunches: "This book is just an old man fishing, but I guess it's a little sad in the end," I thought. I knew something with my claim was wrong. After all, The Old Man and the Sea is one of the best-known books of a man who won the Pulitzer Prize and Nobel Prize for his writing. The Old Man and the Sea is a short read, about 130 pages. I decided to reread the novel, and this time, I understood things that were invisible to me before, picked up new details, and got an idea of the theme. You see, The Old Man and the Sea is not a book to read for its action, drama, or humor, but rather for its true philosophy. This novel is a true example of life lessons being conveyed through simplicity (there are only two named characters!). 

Santiago is a fisherman. As one would expect, he fishes. However, there is a problem. Santiago is incredibly unlucky. As stated at the beginning of the novel, he has gone eighty-four days without catching a single fish. His village ridicules him. His apprentice, a young man named Manolin, is often told to change mentors, but out of his deep affection and admiration for the old man, Manolin stays. 

Reading this book for the first time, here is what I saw for the rest of the pages: Santiago is old but wants actually to catch a fish, so he goes pretty far and through many hardships to catch a big marlin, but unfortunately his effort takes a toll on him. He is severely injured and probably died (it's not explicitly stated if he dies or not, but there foreshadowing throughout the book hints Santiago's death). I closed the book and thought: "Ha! How boring. And some plot twist that was at the end, I pretty much knew from the beginning it was gonna be a sad ending! There's no action, the old man's not even that likable, and I don't even know where Manolin went. Hardly an adventure." 

Opening the book again here is what I read: Santiago is a poor old man who has a heavy burden of balancing his decaying reputation in his village, a horrible streak of luck, and keeping the few that look up to him happy. Alienation, societal, and personal pressures have taken the better of him, and he has finally decided, on the eighty-fifth day of his unlucky streak, to go farther than any fisherman ever before where there will undoubtedly be a big fish. His journey was difficult, but he finally finds his prize marlin. One striking scene from the book for me was when Santiago held the line that connected him and his marlin for three days. Multiple times he dreams of African lions playing on the beach. He is physically tarnished, yet his determination keeps him going. His pride shall not falter, and he will not let go of the thing that is a testament of his worthiness as a fisherman. "Pain does not matter to a man," he remarks. His marlin is attacked by sharks and is torn to shreds, but Santiago will not let go. He fights the sharks with a makeshift knife and harpoon, once again proving his determination. He has to kill the marlin, but he feels as if it has killed his glory along with the marlin. He returns back home with a new feeling of revitalization, though he knows he is at the end of his journey in life. The book closes as he falls asleep dreaming of the lions. 

Two emotions struck me after closing the book for the second time. Guilt, for underestimating a book with a much deeper meaning than I had initially thought, and satisfaction following. Instead of scanning the book to get it over with, the second time around the struggles of the old Santiago suddenly felt a lot more real to me. At the same time, his persistence struck a chord to me that I would never forget the tune of. The Old Man and the Sea was a book that represented many of Hemingway's interests as an author. He was an adventurous person, but at the same time believed that endurance was the solution to many struggles in life. Santiago's unflinching pride until the end was a lesson that Manolin learned and would be able to pass on for several generations. The marlin that Santiago had formed such a deep connection with dying, I think was directly correlated with Santiago's eternal slumber. I think another lesson readers can take away from this applies to every book - read a book once for its story, read it twice for its meaning. Overall The Old Man and the Sea, though not the most enjoyable read, was an experience that changed the way I read. 

My rating:
9.5/10

Comments

  1. Great review! I liked how you talked about reading the book twice, and getting a deeper meaning from it a second time through. You mention some specific moments from the novel, such as when Santiago dreams of lions, but I would have liked it if you talked more about what they represented in the book. Hopefully you will find Hemingway's other works more enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You used a different review format, and it was well executed. I understood everything happening in the story just from your summary. I liked how you shared your thoughts and emotions you felt while reading the book. Good job, and I hope to read this book soon.

    ReplyDelete
  3. From what I've heard, this book isn't that great and it lacks quality. Your review has changed my perception quite a bit. You really describe the pivotal points in the book and you establish that this book has an underlying theme to it. I also like how you talk about the past and present perspectives of yourself reading this book. Good job, and I hope to read your next post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think you said some really interesting things about this book. I like how you talked about rereading it, and understanding it more the second time, because I often do the same things. I also felt the same way after reading The Old Man and the Sea - it certainly was a unique experience. Great review!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Phantom Tollbooth Review - Jashan Takhar

Due to popular opinion among my classmates at the time, I expected The Phantom Tollbooth by Norton Juster to be a "really awesome good book" as a 5th grader several years ago. I read it, understood some of it, did not love it, and forgot it. The older-style writing bored me very quickly and I had thought back then that to fully enjoy a book it had to be fifteen years or younger. Now, going back to this children's classic, I can now comprehend the genius world-building and execution of The Phantom Tollbooth . Milo is a normal boy, who is extremely bored one day when he finds a strange package addressed to him that he does not know the contents of. He finds a tollbooth that he has to put together inside as well as a small electric car. He finishes the tollbooth, steps inside, and is immediately transported to the Lands Beyond. He finds himself suddenly driving on a road, an activity that he enjoys and thus continues doing. Little does he know that he is about to make new ...

Heartless (So Far)
John Brownridge

     During quarantine, I have been doing many things I don't usually get the chance to, like writing, reading superhero comics, practicing Karate, watching Anime ect. What I haven't been doing enough of, however is reading. That's why I am only about halfway through Heartless right now. Anyway, here are my thoughts.       Heartless is a book about a world that is based on a deck of cards. There are Kings, Jokers,  Jacks, ect.. The book takes place in the Kingdom of Hearts, where there is a King, but no queen. The story follows Catherine, who is a normal citizen of the kingdom, who's dream is to open a bake shop with her maid and best friend, Mary Ann. She learned to bake from many cook books in her mansion, and has gotten very good at it, gaining attention from the King himself, who wants to marry her. Catherine's  mom wants nothing less than for her daughter to be the queen, and would do anything to make this a reality. Catherine however...

Why Albrek's Tomb Was a Disappointment (so far)

John Brownridge

      Adventurers Wanted: Albrek's Tomb, the third book in the Adventurers wanted series follows Alexander Taylor (goes by Alex) as he is requested by one of his old company members to find Albrek, a dwarf who went missing searching for new mines in the village of Thraxon.  Alex and his company have to go through many dangerous places to get to Thraxon in search of Albrek, and run into trouble along the way.        I really liked the first two books in the Adventurers Wanted series, Slagboth's gold , and The Horn of Moran. Slagboth's gold  and The Horn of Moran  were Alex's first two adventures, which introduced me to the fantasy world of magic and adventures, all throughout the book. It was fun to see Alex adapt from being a normal sixteen year old kid, to an adventurer on a quest to find gold, having to slay dragons in the process. I was able to experience getting to know magic in the world for the first time with Alex, and it was f...